DEBORAH HOULDING WRONGLY CLAIMS That WHOLE SIGN HOUSES Were Not Used BY ANCIENT ASTROLOGERS - THEY WERE

[JUPITERASC]

*


REFUTING Deborah Houldings whole sign house denialism claim

by showing actual screenshots from ancient astrological texts
from Ancient Greek, Arabic & Latin

that were translated into English by Eduardo Gramaglia & Ben Dykes


Astrologer Deborah Houlding makes the claim
that no historical astrologer defined, discussed, recommended or said
that he was using whole sign houses.
What is relevant is what Deborah Houlding said.
And she said whole sign houses did not exist prior to the 1990s.

No one has denied the existence or importance of the equal & quadrant house systems.

Martin Gansten is also questioning the existence of WSH, but he is far more careful in his posts.

At any rate, have confirmed their existence with this video
as well as long participation in Deborah's topic
and
did so with Greek, Arabic, Persian & Latin translations of texts AND charts

Deb Houlding and whole sign houses - Skyscript Astrology Forum

Thanks to Bulgarian astrologer Dimitar Kojuharov, who found it & had it translated
I show the only surviving horoscope of the Sassanian/Persian empire.
It is for the coronation of king Khosrow I Anushirvan.
It is from 531 AD & only whole sign houses were used.




Fiodor Gruzinev published the book of Andrusar Ibn Zabi Al Farukh
which was found by the 16h century Danish count - astrologer Heinrich Rantzau.
In this book, titled “..Специалният начин за тълкуване на хороскопа..”
- "..The Special Way of Reading the Horoscope.."
Arabic astrologer Andrusar Ibn Zabi Al Farukh
explicitly advocates the use of whole sign houses.

Translation from the book from native Bulgarian.
Gruzinev finished the book in December 1964 & it was circulating in secrecy
due to the communist regime suppressing Astrology.
After the fall of communism, the book was officially published in 1993 in Bulgarian.
- also quote main teacher Robert Zoller who explicitly taught to use both quadrant & whole sign houses.
He knew Latin & translated parts of 13th century Italian astrologer Guido Bonatti.

Whole sign houses has been the main system in India historically, which remains so to this day
and
astrologers who practice Indian Astrology do not even use the MC.
Yet, unlike Deborah Houlding who engages in whole sign house denialism
Jyotishis do not engage in quadrant house denialism

.

 

[JUPITERASC]

*

*


REFUTING Deborah Houldings whole sign house denialism claim

by showing actual screenshots from ancient astrological texts
from Ancient Greek, Arabic & Latin

that were translated into English by Eduardo Gramaglia & Ben Dykes


Astrologer Deborah Houlding makes the claim
that no historical astrologer defined, discussed, recommended or said
that he was using whole sign houses.
What is relevant is what Deborah Houlding said.
And she said whole sign houses did not exist prior to the 1990s.

No one has denied the existence or importance of the equal & quadrant house systems.

Martin Gansten is also questioning the existence of WSH, but he is far more careful in his posts.

At any rate, have confirmed their existence with this video
as well as long participation in Deborah's topic
and
did so with Greek, Arabic, Persian & Latin translations of texts AND charts

Deb Houlding and whole sign houses - Skyscript Astrology Forum

Thanks to Bulgarian astrologer Dimitar Kojuharov, who found it & had it translated
I show the only surviving horoscope of the Sassanian/Persian empire.
It is for the coronation of king Khosrow I Anushirvan.
It is from 531 AD & only whole sign houses were used.




Fiodor Gruzinev published the book of Andrusar Ibn Zabi Al Farukh
which was found by the 16h century Danish count - astrologer Heinrich Rantzau.
In this book, titled “..Специалният начин за тълкуване на хороскопа..”
- "..The Special Way of Reading the Horoscope.."
Arabic astrologer Andrusar Ibn Zabi Al Farukh
explicitly advocates the use of whole sign houses.

Translation from the book from native Bulgarian.
Gruzinev finished the book in December 1964 & it was circulating in secrecy
due to the communist regime suppressing Astrology.
After the fall of communism, the book was officially published in 1993 in Bulgarian.
- also quote main teacher Robert Zoller who explicitly taught to use both quadrant & whole sign houses.
He knew Latin & translated parts of 13th century Italian astrologer Guido Bonatti.

Whole sign houses has been the main system in India historically, which remains so to this day
and
astrologers who practice Indian Astrology do not even use the MC.
Yet, unlike Deborah Houlding who engages in whole sign house denialism
Jyotishis do not engage in quadrant house denialism

.